The College Football Czar
Week
17
Week sixteen in review: The first-round playoff games stunk. Really, they did. Then again, so does the whole concept, so we
shouldn't be surprised. The home team
won each of the four contests, and although two of the final scores ended up
being respectable, none of the outcomes was ever in doubt. By the nature of tournament play, there are
mismatches, especially in the beginning.
It wouldn't be fair to have two very good teams like Penn State and
Notre Dame play each other in one game, and two teams that barely made the cut,
like SMU and Indiana, in another. Those
would have been very plausible bowl matchups, however, if not for the
ill-conceived playoff expansion.
The one positive facet of the
first-round games was that they were not neutral-site games, but were instead
played at the home fields of the higher seeds.
This provided a great atmosphere, at least at the beginning of each
game, just as the creators of this format had hoped. That itself is problematic, however, because
the quarterfinal and semifinal games are to be held at bowl sites, where they
are taking up residence like hermit crabs.
The first quarterfinal, for example, is masquerading as the Fiesta Bowl,
a neutral-site indoor game in Glendale, Arizona. Wouldn't it be better for the game if PSU had
to take its spiffy white road uniforms up to Boise to play on the blue
turf? In addition to that being a more
enjoyable experience for the viewers, it would be better for attendance. Last year, Washington had trouble selling all
of its tickets to the CFP championship in Houston, because the Husky fans had
just traveled to New Orleans for a "Sugar Bowl" semifinal the week before. Understandably, not many of the same people
were able to make those back-to-back 2,500-mile road trips. In the current format, each of the finalists
will now be playing its third neutral-site game in a row. This cannot help but encourage a move to
on-campus sites for every game preceding the championship.
So, where does that leave the bowl
games? The argument that the bowls could
coexist with a playoff by being integrated into the format is in the process of
being refuted. This means that in the
very near future, none of the 12 playoff teams (which will become 16 before you
know it) will be playing in bowl games.
Who plays in the Rose Bowl, then?
The #4 selection from the Big Ten and the #3 selection from the Big
XII? Moreover, if the Rose Bowl matchup
is one that might traditionally have been made at the Sun Bowl, then who is the
Sun Bowl going to get? The NCAA's
planned, slow-motion destruction of the bowl games will then shift into fast
forward. The prestige of the games will
be gone, and the finances will soon follow.
College football fans are used to
having enjoyable, usually evenly-matched football games on TV on a daily basis
throughout the Christmas season. By
contrast, take a look at this year's playoff schedule: one game on Dec. 20th,
three on Dec. 21st, one on New Year's Eve, three on New Year's Day, one on Jan.
9th, one on Jan. 10th, and one on Jan. 20th.
That's eleven games scattered over an entire month, as opposed to a
nightly celebration of football, culminating in a grand finale of blockbuster
games on New Year's Day. This is what
The Powers That Be Stupid have been telling us we've been demanding all our
lives. The College Football Czar, for
one, has never, ever wanted it, and now that it is upon us, he doesn't want it
twice as much. That may not be literate,
but it's true.
For the past couple years, the NCAA
has not even acknowledged the timing of the transfer portal opening to be a
problem, because it served the purpose of diminishing the bowl games. The conventional wisdom has been that we
would never see players transferring out if their teams were in the playoff,
but that is proving to be untrue. Among
others, Penn State second-string quarterback Beau Pribula left the Nittany
Lions prior to their first-round game against SMU. Pribula had appeared in almost every game this
season as a change-of-pace option QB, and his absence could prove critical at
some point. If this happened to a lot of
other teams, it might not make a difference, but when Penn State complains, the
NCAA listens. In this particular case,
that happens to be a good thing.
The College Football Czar lost the
Army-Navy game to finish the regular season with a somewhat disappointing
record of 158-114 for a .581 winning percentage. On his first week's postseason picks, he went
8-3 (.727).
Dec.
27
Armed Forces Bowl -- Fort Worth, TX --
Noon or 3:30 (ESPN)
Navy (8-4) vs. Oklahoma (6-6)
Conventional wisdom says the
triple-option is a detriment in a bowl game, because the opposing coaches have
more time to prepare for it. The results
don't back up that assertion, as the postseason success of the military
academies will attest. The Midshipmen
are 12-11-1 in bowl games, having won 5 of their last 6. Army has a bowl record of 7-3, and Air Force
16-13-1. Furthermore, the academies
don't have to contend with opt-outs, so the same personnel will be running the
Middies' offense as in their 31-13 victory over Army.
The only thing OU needs now is a T,
because about a fourth of their roster has exited by way of the transfer
portal, while NFL-bound linebacker Danny Stutsman and safety Billy Bowman have
betrayed their team for the usual dishonest reason.
Sooner quarterback Jackson Arnold is
among those who have entered the portal, which, frankly, is disappointing. The College Football Czar thought Arnold
would have learned his lesson from that episode in which that unscrupulous
baseball coach tried to get Willis to transfer to another junior high school.
Navy 24, Oklahoma 14
Birmingham Bowl -- Birmingham (no,
really!) -- Noon or 3:30 (ESPN)
Vanderbilt (6-6) vs. Georgia Tech
(7-5)
Each team can take credit for
keeping a powerhouse program out of the playoff, with the Commodores upsetting
Alabama, and Tech tripping up Miami.
Each of them has also thrown a scare into a national championship contender,
Vandy hanging tough in a 27-24 loss to Texas, and the Yellowjackets finally
falling to Georgia in eight overtimes.
VU kept up its momentum after
beating Bama, winning its following two games to improve to 5-2. The 1-4 skid that started at that point does
not indicate a letdown, however, with those losses to SEC powerhouses Texas,
South Carolina, LSU and Tennessee.
It will have been almost four months
since GT quarterback Haynes King threw his last and only interception of the
season, in a nonconference win over crosstown foe Georgia State. He has tossed 11 touchdown passes, including
two in an uncharacteristic 300-yard game against UGA.
Birmingham, being the steel city of
the South, has a huge statue of Vulcan in the middle of town. Mister Spock would not live long and prosper
if he ever tangled with that guy, no matter how much pon farr he had going for him.
Georgia Tech 28, Vanderbilt 27
Liberty Bowl -- Memphis -- 7:00 (ESPN)
Texas Tech (8-4) vs. Arkansas (6-6)
Red Raider QB Behren Morton is
sitting out this game, but he's doing it the old-fashioned way, by being
injured. The junior decided to have
shoulder surgery at the end of this regular season, in hopes that he will be
ready to go for the 2025 season opener.
In his place will be freshman Will Hammond, who played well earlier this
season in a tough loss to TCU.
In hindsight, the Razorbacks must be
ashamed of a Week 2 overtime loss to Oklahoma State, but the most damaging of
their five SEC defeats has been to 9-3 Missouri, and they toppled Tennessee in
Week 6. Leading receiver Andrew
Armstrong has stretched his 6-4 frame to catch 78 passes for 1,140 yards. Strangely, he has only a single touchdown,
down from 13 two years ago, when he gained less yardage.
In honor of Patrick Henry, the
winners of this game are given liberty, whereas the losers are given
death. Unless, of course, they opt out
of death, which everybody always does.
Some of these NCAA regulations are even sillier than others.
Arkansas 30, Texas Tech 18
Holiday Bowl -- San Diego -- 8:00 (FOX)
Syracuse (9-3) vs. Washington State
(8-4)
Contrary to early media speculation,
Cuse quarterback Kyle McCord is adamant that he is playing in this game. Coach Fran Brown explained his star player's
decision like this: "The more football
you play, the more the NFL watches."
Yeah, but does he realize they'll be watching a guy who's completely
unprepared for the draft?
There was a time when one might have
wondered what the CFP committee was going to do with Wazzu. There it was at 8-1, with good wins against
Texas Tech and Washington, and having been beaten only by Boise State on the
road. Three terrible losses later,
problem solved. In the end, the Cougars
didn't even win the championship of the two-team Pac 12. And that was before prolific dual threat QB
John Mateer transferred to Oklahoma.
This being the Holiday Bowl, the
college Football Czar would like to extend Holiday wishes to all those who are
celebrating Holiday by attending Holiday parties and "gifting" each other
Holiday presents. His wish is that they
cease to be such insufferable barfbrains.
Syracuse 49, Washington State 27
Las Vegas Bowl -- Las Vegas, strangely
enough -- 10:30 (ESPN)
Texas A&M (8-4) vs. USC (6-6)
The Trojans traditionally blow off
their bowl games, but perhaps this time they'll play with a little pride, now
that they are overmatched to start out with.
They did play hard in their regular season finale at Notre Dame, but
lost 49-35. They were 21 yards away from
tying the game in the fourth quarter, until QB Jayden Maiava threw two
pick-sixes on consecutive possessions, the first one for 99 yards, and the
second one for 100.
The Conjunction Boys were on the
boxcar that followed the "and" this season, as they seemed like an SEC
afterthought even when they sat at the top of the standings late in the
season. Unfortunately, this widespread skepticism
was well founded, as demonstrated by the fact that the Aggies crapped out in
their last three conference games.
Allegiant Stadium has a grass
surface for Raider games, which can be rolled outside so that it can get some
sun, much like the field the Cardinals play on in Glendale, Arizona. For college games in Vegas, the field is left
out in the open air, while the concrete surface that is left behind is covered
with a carpet. UNLV, which plays its
home games in this same stadium, says it actually prefers the artificial turf. Wanna bet?
Texas A&M 42, USC 31
Dec. 28
Fenway Bowl -- Boston -- 11AM (ESPN)
North Carolina (6-6) vs. Uconn (8-4)
Sports teams love to play up the "us
against the world" shtick, but it's almost always embellished if not fabricated
outright. Not so in the case of the Conn
Men, who were openly disdained by their own university five years ago, when it
cast them adrift as an Independent while returning to the Big East for
basketball. Nevertheless, the Huskies
have had their best season since 2010, albeit against a lot of lower-echelon
American Athletic Conference opponents.
They are 0-3 this year against the ACC, however, having been beaten by
Duke, Wake Forest and Syracuse.
Running back Omarion Hampton, who
was second in the nation in rushing during the regular season, will not be
suiting up for UNC. You already know
why. At the end of a lengthy social
media post, Hampton wrote, "after much thought and prayer, I am officially
announcing that I will be declaring for the 2025 NFL draft." OK, great!
Nothing about that means he isn't still a Tar Heel, with an obligation
to play, for the simple reason that the 2024 North Carolina Tar Heels are
playing a football game. Next season is
not until next season. This is still
this season. That's why we call it that.
If you're watching this game and
you're lucky, you'll catch a glimpse of the Green Monster. That'll be the guy who started getting warmed
up for this pre-noon bowl game without having breakfast first.
North Carolina 38, Uconn 31
Pinstripe Bowl -- New York -- Noon
(ABC)
Nebraska (6-6) vs. Boston College
(7-5)
The Bostonians won in their own
ballpark a year ago, shocking SMU 23-14 in the Fenway Bowl. Now they invade enemy territory, as they
bring a little flavor of Beantown to the Bronx.
They haven't handled the hostility well in two previous Pinstripe Bowls,
losing to Penn State in 2014 and Iowa in 2017.
The Cornhuskers were 5-1 before they
got the niblets beaten out of them at Indiana,
56-7. Their next game after that, they
only lost to Ohio State 21-17, but then the bottom fell out in back-to-back
blunders against Big Ten newcomers UCLA and USC. Since the start of October, freshman QB Dylan
Raiola has thrown only three TDs, and eight interceptions.
Grayson James took over at
quarterback for the Eagles during a Week 11 win over Syracuse, eventually
causing previous starter Thomas Castellanos to transfer. James is now auditioning for next year's job,
with coach Bill O'Brien having plucked freshman Dylan Lonegran
from Alabama through the portal. One
thing that's working in James' favor is that BC might need to keep him around
to fulfill its quota of Graysons, whereas you can
pick up another Dylan just about anywhere.
One look at the N-men, and you can
see that pinstripes do not agree with them.
Too fancy.
Boston College 14, Nebraska 10
New Mexico Bowl -- Albuquerque -- 2:30
(ESPN)
La.-Lafayette (10-3) vs. TCU (8-4)
Ragin Cajun QB Ben Woodridge hopes
to be back in the lineup, after his backups took a bruising in a 31-3 Sun Belt
championship loss to Marshall. Even if
he plays, he'll have a tough time keeping up with Horned Frog hurler Josh
Hoover, who needs 303 yards to reach 4,000 for the season.
There are four teams in the Big XII
that tied for first place with a conference record of 7-2 (Arizona State,
Brigham Young, Iowa State and Colorado).
This Texas Christian team, which finished a game behind at 6-3, did not
have to face any of them. In Week 9,
they rallied from a 17-point second-half deficit to beat Texas Tech 35-34, but
that has been their only victory against a team that finished the season with a
non-losing record.
If it's New Mexico, does that
mean the beans are just plain fried?
TCU 45, La-Lafayette 28
Pop Tarts Bowl -- Orlando -- 3:30 (ABC)
Iowa State (10-3) vs. Miami (10-2)
Hurricane coach Mario Cristobal made
a halfhearted argument for his team to have been included in the playoff after
blowing a 21-0 lead at Syracuse, but the absence of a marquee win made two
upset losses in November too much to overcome.
The Cyclones were already trailing
the Big XII championship game, 24-10 at halftime against Arizona State, when
they turned the ball over on three consecutive possessions in the third
quarter. The result was a 45-19 romp,
even though their pass defense, ranked third nationally, held up pretty well.
Against the run, ISU got stomped by
Sun Devil RB Cam Skattebo, and now it takes on a Cane ground game that is more
effective than ASU's. The U doesn't get
as much use out of the run as a lot of other teams, but it averages 5.5 yards
per carry.
The festivities surrounding this
game give way to a macabre postgame ceremony in which a smiling,
anthropomorphic pop tart mascot is plunged into a giant toaster and cooked to
death, and then devoured by members of the winning team. It's kind of like a conspicuous product
placement during a sequel to Apocalypto, except that not even Mel Gibson
is this demented.
Miami 30, Iowa State 14
Arizona Bowl -- Tucson -- 4:30 (CW)
Miami OH (8-5) vs. Colorado State
(8-4)
Senior running back Avery Morrow has
provided more O to the Rams this season, needing 44 yards to become their first
1,000-yard rusher since 2017. The entire
team amassed only 1,114 yards on the ground all of last season, a total they
will roughly double this year.
The RedHawks got rolled by the
round-at-both-ends Bobcats, 38-3 in the MAC championship game. They were held to 189 total yards, which is
par for the course for them in the postseason.
In the past decade, MU is 1-4 in bowls, while averaging only 17.8 points
per game.
The full title of this game is now
the Snoop Dogg Arizona Bowl presented by Gin & Juice, yet its lardhead
quotient has plummeted. That's because
it will no longer be announced by the smugly stupid circus freaks from Barstool
Sports. Those lardheads
who are watching at home will need to be witty enough to laugh at the players
wearing uniform #69 all by themselves.
Colorado State 26, Miami OH 16
Military Bowl -- Annapolis -- 5:45
(ESPN)
East Carolina (7-5) vs. Nc State
(6-6)
These familiar foes face off in a
bowl game for the second time, with the Pirates having poured it on in the
fourth quarter of a 37-34 Peach Bowl victory to finish the 1991 season. State leads the overall series 19-13, most
recently taking a 21-20 tussle in 2022.
ECU has already taken the interim
tag off head coach Blake Harrell, and it's not hard to see why. Since dismissing Mike Houston after a 3-4
start, they have gone 4-1 under the elevated defensive coordinator, who finally
lost a game against Navy to end the regular season.
Gangly freshman C. J. Bailey has
started at QB for the Wolfpack for most of the year. Meanwhile, M. J. Morris, who abandoned NCSU while
he was its starter last season in order to preserve his redshirt, has
started two games for Maryland, during which he has thrown five
interceptions. No wonder the wolf on the
Pack helmet appears to be laughing.
Nc State 32, East Carolina 30
Alamo Bowl -- San Antonio -- 7:30 (ABC)
Brigham Young (10-2) vs. Colorado
(9-3)
Two teams from the same conference
meet in a bowl game for the first time since Nevada beat Colorado State 28-23
in the 2015 Arizona Bowl. For what it's
worth, it was arguably the best game of that bowl season, even though nobody
had wanted it to happen.
Coach Prime says his players don't
opt out, and so far they agree with him.
At this point, neither his son Shedeur nor Heisman-winner Travis Hunter
has abandoned the Buffaloes to "prepare for the draft," and why would they?
Deion himself had no such preparation, and was drafted in two sports
anyway. Heck, he wasn't even prepared to
run away from Tim McCarver like a wussy, but when the time came, he was up to
the task.
The Cougars kept CU out of the Big
XII title game when they handled Houston 30-18 to end the regular season. Playing spoiler was the best they could do,
because they could no longer play for the championship themselves, following
back-to-back losses to Kansas and Arizona State. Their decline started while they were still
on a winning streak, however. The last
game that could really be considered a good win for them was when they
clobbered Kansas State way back in Week 4
The defenders of the Alamo didn't
actually win, but Jim Bowie did that "seepy-bye" pose when he killed one of
Santa Ana's men, and it was so cool!
Colorado 34, Brigham Young 29
Independence Bowl -- Shreveport -- 9:15
(ESPN)
Army (11-1) vs. Louisiana Tech (5-7)
The Sun Belt Conference is
considering punitive action against its own champion, Marshall, for pulling out
of this game after already accepting the invitation. When head coach Charles Huff was hired away
by conference rival Southern Miss, about a third of the Thundering Herd roster
entered the transfer portal. Obviously,
the remaining moo-men would have been at a disadvantage against the Black
Knights, but they surely could have still played. Even with all their losses, they still had
almost as many players as a college football team typically takes on a road
trip.
If you're wondering why a coaching
change would cause such a mass exodus, you don't have to look any farther than
Colorado. Two years ago, newly hired
coach Deion Sanders showed up to address his new team, and he told the players
he had no use for most of them, so they should get out. By leaving on their own terms, at least these
guys can be sure that wherever they land, it will be someplace where they're
wanted.
What if Army hadn't played Notre
Dame this year? It might have been
awarded the group-of-five playoff spot at 12-0 after winning the AAC
championship, only to lose to Navy six days later. Then, what could the committee have
said? "Sorry, Boise State, but you
shouldn't have scheduled Oregon."
The College Football Czar would like
to tell you not to dismiss LTU even though they are a replacement opponent that
would otherwise be ineligible. Never
mind. This Bulldog team has been beaten
by Tulsa, Florida International and New Mexico State. Dismiss away.
Army 52, Louisiana Tech 17
Dec. 30
Music City Bowl -- Nashville -- 2:30
(ESPN)
Iowa (8-4) vs. Missouri (9-3)
Hawkeye running back Kaleb Johnson,
who leads the Big Ten with 1,537 rushing yards, has decided to skip this game
in order to -- all together now -- "prepare for the draft." He can't be ready for the draft in less than
five months? He's not as speedy as he
looks. His absence creates an
opportunity for freshman Kamari Moulton, who broke out in Week 13 against
Maryland, for 114 yards on 12 carries.
The Tigers' 9-3 record is more than
a little deceptive. Not only were there
three gimmes on their nonconference schedule, but all five of their SEC
victories were against teams in the lower half of the league. Against opponents that are currently ranked,
they're 0-3.
When Mizzou accepted an invitation
to the Music City bowl, they thought it was being played in Branson. They shouldn't be too disappointed, though,
because Nashville is just like a really big Branson, that is ever so slightly
less drunk.
Iowa 17, Missouri 13
Dec. 31
ReliaQuest Bowl -- Tampa -- Noon (ESPN)
Michigan (7-5) vs. Alabama (9-3)
The Crimson Tide are convinced they
should have gotten the last playoff bid instead of SMU. With two losses to .500 teams, they don't
have that much of an argument, but they'd have a chance to put on a convincing
show against an undermanned U of M offense.
The Wolverines are seventh-worst in
the nation in total yardage gained, at 294.3 total yards per game. A 50-6 blowout of Northwestern in Week 13 has
been the only game all year long in which they put more than 30 points on the
board. Their passing game in particular
is even worse, ranking fifth from the bottom.
If they had to go to war with QB Davis Warren, they would gain ground
about as rapidly as the Russian army.
Pachyderm passer Jalen Milroe has not thrown a touchdown pass against a Division
I-A opponent since a Week 8 loss to Tennessee.
In a Week 13 meltdown at Oklahoma, he completed only 11 of 26 for 164
yards with three interceptions, one of which was returned for a score. That 24-3 thumping was not easy to watch, but
it needs to be seen by anybody who thinks the problem with the current playoff
format is that it left this Alabama team out.
What is ReliaQuest,
you ask? It's a new movie in which the
heroine is the sister of Johnny Quest, who happens to be a blackbelt psychic
marine biologist. Well, not really, but
can the truth possibly be much better?
Alabama 20, Michigan 12
Sun Bowl -- El Paso -- 2:00 (CBS)
Washington (6-6) vs. Louisville (8-4)
Cardinal QB Tyler Shough has finally
had the kind of season that's been expected of him, with 3,195 passing yards,
23 TDs and only six interceptions. If
the sixth-year senior can finish a season without a serious injury, he could
have a future in the NFL. For this
reason, he is opting out, which actually reinforces fears about his physical
durability. If he really wants to
reassure the scouts, he cannot afford to show that he's afraid to play a
football game.
With everything the Huskies had lost
since last year's run to the championship game, first-year coach Jedd Fisch
might have done a better job in producing this .500 record than he did in
winning ten games last season at Arizona.
The last three losses for UW have all been to playoff teams, and in the
meantime they have beaten both USC and UCLA.
The Ville took a nasty spill at
Stanford in Week 1?, surrendering 17 points in the last seven minutes of a
38-35 shocker, which was aided by a pair of undisciplined penalties that set up
the decisive field goal. Rather than let
their season disintegrate at that point, they responded with decisive victories
against Pitt (37-9) and Kentucky (41-14) to end the regular season.
It's a little-known fact that nobody
in El Paso knows the words to the song "El Paso." That's because Marty Robbins sang it in
English.
Louisville 16, Washington 7
Citrus Bowl -- Orlando -- 3:00 (ABC)
Illinois (9-3) vs. South Carolina
(9-3)
The Citrus Bowl is sponsored by a
truss that you sit in. Just what the
College Football Czar needs, after four solid months of carcass-parking.
Before Alabama waters down its
nonconference schedule in an attempt to maximize its record for CFP purposes,
it might ask itself where the Gamecocks would be if they'd beaten three better
teams than Old Dominion, Akron and Division I-AA Wofford. This Carolina team finished with the same
record as the Crimson Tide, but never got a moment's consideration for the
playoff, and this is the biggest reason why.
Fighting Illini wide receiver Pat
Bryant will not reach the 1,000-yard mark this season, because he has opted
out, rather than risk injury before the NFL draft. Seriously, why did he bother playing his
team's last regular season game against Northwestern, then? Would he not have gotten drafted all the
same? He could have jeopardized his
professional career by getting injured in that meaningless game!
Also opting out is SC defensive end
Kyle Kennard, who leads the SEC in sacks with 11.5. Had he played this game, he could have broken
Jadeveon Clowney's school record by adding two more to that total. Would that not have been a valuable addition
to his resume? If he doesn't care about
that, and he's only concerned about getting injured, then what in the world was
he doing on the field for that Wofford game in mid-November?
These players all want to be paid
for their image now, but what if their image is that of a bunch of disloyal
girlie-men with no capacity for logic, who suddenly develop an irrational fear
of playing football?
South Carolina 28, Illinois 13
Texas Bowl -- Houston -- 3:30 (ESPN)
LSU (8-4) vs. Baylor (8-4)
With 3,739 passing yards, Garrett
Nussmeier of Louisiana State is second in the SEC, only to Ole miss QB Jaxson
Dart. The flip side is that the Tigers
are dead last in the conference in rushing yardage. During a late-season three-game losing streak
to Texas A&M, Alabama and Florida, they only ran for an average of 83.3
yards.
The College Football Czar was going
to explain what "flip side" means, but then he realized he doesn't have to,
because vinyl records have been making a comeback. If this wave of nostalgia hits the world of
sports fandom, the Czar and his collection of Lucky Stripes hats are ready!
BU blew a chance to play for the Big
XII title with its Week 4 collapse against Colorado, which concluded with a
goal-line fumble in overtime. Subsequent
losses to BYU and Iowa State dropped its record to 2-4, before it rallied to
win its last six, to finish one game back.
The Bears have gone with a Mark
Twain theme at quarterback this year. Their original starter was a guy named
Finn, but since he got injured, Sawyer has stepped in for him. Might there be a Pudd'nhead
waiting in the wings? Considering
college football's affinity for oddly placed apostrophes, don't be
surprised. Then, we could count on
clever TV analysts to say witty things like, "He's on my All-Name Team." Where do they come up with that stuff?
LSU 34, Baylor 31
CFP Quarterfinal (Fiesta Bowl) --
Glendale, AZ -- 7:30 (ESPN)
Penn State (12-2) vs. Boise State
(12-1)
A lot has been said about how Penn
State has received a remarkably favorable playoff draw for a team that failed
to win its conference championship. That
should make good bulletin board material for BSU, but last time the College
Football Czar checked, the game isn't played on bulletin boards, although that
wouldn't be much sillier than the blue turf back in Boise.
Bronco tailback Ashton Jeanty is 131
yards away from breaking Barry Sanders' record for rushing yards in a season,
but that's a record that would need to be marked with an asterisk the size of
the one that was headed for Earth in Armageddon. The regular season is one game longer than it
was in 1988, and there are conference championship games, meaning that Jeanty's
current total is based on 13 games, and Sanders' on 11. Furthermore, The Powers That Be Stupid did
not count bowl stats on a player's season record when Sanders was playing. If they did, then the 222 yards he gained in
the Holiday Bowl against Wyoming would make it extremely unlikely that Jeanty
could catch him, even with the playoff giving him a three-game advantage.
Yes, the Broncs outplayed Oregon
except for special teams in a last-second 37-34 setback in Week 2, but opposing
QB Dillon Gabriel was just getting accommodated to his new offense. That Fighting Duck team bore little
resemblance to the one the Nittany Lions battled to the end of an exciting
45-37 Big Ten title game in Indianapolis.
Okay, so it's an asteroid, not an
asterisk. So we're going for realism
now? Have you seen this movie?
Well, no, the College Football Czar
hasn't seen it either, but that's hardly the point.
Penn State 33, Boise State 17
CFP Quarterfinal (Peach Bowl) --
Atlanta -- 1:00 (ESPN)
Texas (12-2) vs. Arizona State (11-2)
The 336 passing yards the Longhorns
allowed in last week's 38-24 win over Clemson should have come as no surprise,
because Cade Klubnik was clearly a rung above any of
the other QBs they've faced all season.
Looking back, their biggest wins against Michigan, Oklahoma and Texas
A&M did not require them to go up against a proficient passer. Ole Miss was not on their SEC schedule, and
neither was LSU, Tennessee or Missouri.
They could be playing with fire this week when they face Sun Devil
freshman Sam Leavitt, who has 2,663 yards and 24 TDs.
How valuable is Leavitt to ASU? In the one game he missed due to a rib
injury, his team was beaten by Cincinnati, which was able to concentrate on
containing RB Cam Skattebo. Since his
return to the lineup, they have won six in a row, including a 45-19 Big Ten
championship game romp over Iowa State.
The Sun Devils have won six games by
eight points or fewer, and most of those against lesser opponents like
Mississippi State, Texas State, Utah and Central Florida. They could not have won a power conference
title if they didn't play in a league that had been devalued by the loss of its
best team. That, of course, is Texas,
which might still be undefeated if it had avoided Georgia by continuing to play
in the Big XII.
Why do they still call it the Big
XII, when it now has 16 teams? Is XVI harder
to spell?
Texas 45, Arizona State 41
CFP Quarterfinal (Rose Bowl) --
Pasadena -- 5:00 (ESPN)
Ohio State (11-2) vs. Oregon (13-0)
The lumpy nuts lost a tough one to
UO back in Week 7, but that was a road game, decided by the narrowest of
margins (32-31), in which one could easily make the case for OSU having gotten
the better of the play. Now they have a
second chance, this time at a neutral site, and with a win they would instantly
become the favorite to take the national title.
But should they have gotten this chance?
The Buckeyes were already on course for a rematch with the Fighting
Ducks in the Big Ten championship game, but they blew it by losing to a
mediocre Michigan team. The CFP was
created for the purpose of ensuring that the best team in the nation is crowned
champion, not creating an NFL-like situation in which the tenth best team can
win it all. If Ohio State finishes the
season with a loss to Oregon and another loss to Michigan, and Oregon finishes
with only a loss to Ohio State, are the Buckeyes really the best?
OSU is now widely expected to win this
rematch, partly because of the way they rallied around Coach Brutus to trounce
Tennessee, 42-17. This week they will
not be at home in the horseshoe, nor will they be frustrating a freshman
quarterback who had been burdened by excessive expectations. Instead, they must stop Dillon Gabriel, the
most experienced QB in college football, who has topped the 3,500-yard mark for
the fourth time in his career.
The Duck defensive front was
manhandled by Penn State in an unsettling 45-37 victory in the Big Ten title
game, in which they were gashed for 297 rushing yards, for an average of 8.7
per carry. But isn't the Buckeye
offensive line more powerful than PSU's?
For the first time in quite a few years, the answer is a resounding
no. The O-State O-line has been beset
with injuries all season, and it showed when their offense turned south against
The Team Up North, in a bitter 13-10 defeat.
First-year Buckeye offensive
coordinator Chip Kelly gets a second shot at his former team since arriving in
Columbus, but in addition to failing to beat them as an assistant earlier this
year, he went 0-4 against the Big O when he was head coach at UCLA. His only greater streak of futility came in
youth football, where he was unsuccessful at every place kick he ever
attempted, because Lucy kept pulling the ball away.
Oregon 28, Ohio State 25
CFP Quarterfinal (Sugar Bowl) -- New
Orleans -- 8:45 (ESPN)
Notre Dame (12-1) vs. Georgia (11-2)
Until their first-round 27-17 win
over Indiana, the Fighting Irish were the forgotten team of the playoff, having
been idle on conference championship weekend.
Had they been in a league, they would have had to play a losable game at
a neutral site in order to earn a first-round bye. They basically traded that for a first-round
mismatch in their favor, and on their home field.
The Bulldogs will be without
starting QB Carson Beck, who has had elbow surgery since suffering a nasty
injury during a 22-19 overtime victory over Texas for the SEC
championship. The question is how great
a detriment this will really be to his team.
The senior had thrown twice as many interceptions as he did a year ago,
and his completion percentage had dropped off by almost eight points. Sophomore Gunner Stockton hasn't exactly been
a howitzer, though. In three appearances
this season, the coaches have kept him throwing safe passes, allowing him to
compile a 78.1 completion percentage, but for only 206 yards on 25 completions.
Judging from the golden domers' schedule, they could have contended for an ACC
title, but as far as the playoff is concerned, how good is that, really? For decades, ND took pride in taking on the
toughest teams in America, but this year their best win is still their opening
23-13 victory at Texas A&M. None of
their opponents contended for its own conference title except for MAC runner-up
Miami Ohio.
The Irish could use all the crowd
support they can get against UGA, but unfortunately for them, Touchdown Jesus will
not be attending the game. That's
because GOD HATES DOMES!
Georgia 20, Notre Dame 17
Jan. 2
Gator Bowl -- Jacksonville -- 7:30
(ESPN)
Duke (9-3) vs. Ole Miss (9-3)
The Blue Devils have sneaked up on a
shot at a 10-win season, even though they haven't played very well. They have seven wins against mediocre
opponents by ten points or fewer, and they lost a game to SMU despite going
plus-6 in turnovers. Just think how many
of these victories could easily have teetered the other way if they had lost QB
Maalik Murphy, who will be absent from this game because he has decided to
transfer to Oregon State.
Hotty Toddy had gotten ploddy
as the season has gone along. Against a
weak early nonconference schedule, the Rebels racked up 220 points in four
games. Once SEC play started, they
scored 28 points or fewer in every game but one. After falling to Florida 24-17, they almost
laid one in the Egg Bowl, a bland 26-14 win over last-place Mississippi State.
The College Football Czar might be
considered a somethingophobe or other for saying
this, but he finds it highly unlikely that someone named Toddy is a hotty.
Ole Miss 24, Duke 7
Jan. 3
First Responder Bowl -- Dallas -- 4:00
(ESPN)
Texas State (7-5) vs. North Texas
(6-6)
3,000 yards would constitute another
successful season for former James Madison QB Jordan McCloud, who needs only 80
yards to reach that mark with the Bobcats.
A year ago at JMU, he threw for 3,675, while leading the Dukes to a
record of 11-2.
The Mean Green lost five in a row
until eking out a 24-17 season-ending win over Temple. They had led that game 24-3 before giving up
two TDs late in the second quarter, and then finished a scoreless second half
by picking off a pass at their own 6-yard-line.
The College Football Czar once
volunteered to be a first responder, and boy did he show his stuff in the
interview. "What is tungsten?" "Who was Buster Crabbe?" "What was the War of the Spanish Succession?"
They didn't give him the job,
though. Haters.
Texas State 55, North Texas 34
Duke's Mayo Bowl -- Charlotte -- 7:30
(ESPN)
Minnesota (7-5) vs. Virginia Tech
(6-6)
Kyron Drones suffered multiple leg
injuries in a Week 9 loss to Clemson.
But, hey, at least it gave him time to travel all over New Jersy and
several neighboring states. Since then,
the starting QB has been a freshman named Pop Watson, who had better be careful
he doesn't get eaten as part of the postgame ceremony.
With the exception of a bad loss at
Iowa, the radiant rodents were right in every game this season. Their other four defeats, to North Carolina,
Michigan, Rutgers and Penn State, were by a total of only 13 points. In Week 13, they kicked a field goal to pull
within a point of Penn State with almost six minutes left, but allowed the
Nittany Lions to run out the clock on a drive that included three fourth-down
conversions.
It has become traditional for the
head coach of the winning team to have a tub of mayonnaise poured over his
head. The College Football Czar dislikes
this because it cuts against one's natural motivation to win. The disincentive shouldn't deter Golden
Gopher coach P.J. Fleck, though, because he has got little to lose by
winning. A rag and a little Windex, and
he's good as new.
Minnesota 35, Virginia Tech 23
Jan. 4
Bahamas Bowl -- Nassau -- 11AM (ESPN2)
Buffalo (8-4) vs. Liberty (8-3)
LU quarterback Kaidon Salter has
entered the transfer portal, but how badly will he be missed? This year, he has only thrown for 1,886 yards
against weak competition, and in his last game, a 20-18 loss to Sam Houston, he
went 12-for-35 with two picks. Is this
guy really supposed to be a replacement for Shedeur Sanders at Colorado next
season?
UB was a .500 team at one point this
season, until it got to a November schedule that consisted of Akron, Ball
State, Eastern Michigan and Kent State. That's
got to be the weakest opposition any Bulls have come across outside of
Pamplona, where a bunch of scrawny Spaniards try to prove their manhood while
running away, while dressed like the wait staff of the world's worst Mexican
restaurant chain.
The only current bow game outside of
the United States returns home after being displaced for a year, while Thomas
A. Robinson Stadium was being renovated.
Can you imagine being one of the teams that played in the Bahamas Bowl
the one year it was displaced to Charlotte?
That would be kind of like getting shipwrecked with only Mrs. Howell.
Buffalo 24, Liberty 20
Jan. 9
CFP Semifinal (Orange Bowl) -- Miami --
7:30 (ESPN)
Predicted matchup: Penn State
(12-2) vs. Georgia (12-2)
Each team is down a quarterback, but
Nittany Lion backup Beau Pribula might prove to be the costlier loss. Pribula gave PSU the ability to disrupt
opposing defenses by making them adjust to the occasional read-option
series. With starter Drew Allar injured
at Wisconsin in Week 9, the sophomore scrambler led his team to two
fourth-quarter touchdown drives to put the game away.
In the SEC championship game, the
Bulldog defense gave up 358 yards to Texas QB Quinn Ewers, but it also sacked
him six times and forced two interceptions.
Expect them to become even more aggressive, against a starter who has
been slowed by an ankle injury, and has nobody with any experience to back him
up. The only other Lion quarterback who
has played at all this year is freshman Ethan Grunkemeyer, who completed one
pass on two attempts for nine yards in the first round against SMU.
For decades, the Orange Bowl logo
was a smiley character, but the orange in the current logo does not assume
human form. That's a good thing, or else
it would probably get skinned and have the life squeezed out of it in front of
65,000 attendees and a massive TV audience.
Come to think of it, if eating quasi-human grocery items is going to
become a postgame tradition, a coach whose head resembles a cashew ought to be
getting a little nervous by now.
Georgia 21, Penn State 19
Jan. 10
CFP Semifinal (Cotton Bowl) --
Arlington, TX -- 7:30 (ESPN)
Predicted matchup: Texas (12-2)
vs. Oregon (14-0)
The U of O is 2-0 in postseason
games against their opponents from Austin, winning the 2000 Holiday Bowl and
then the Alamo Bowl in 2013. None of
this matters to anybody involved in this game but the fans, of course, the more
recent of these results being so many years ago, it was Longhorn head coach
Mack Brown's final game before returning to North Carolina.
The Horns never have put their quarterback
controversy to rest, with Quinn Ewers remaining the starter even though freshman
Arch Manning has been statistically better, in completion percentage, yards per
attempt, and touchdown-to-interception ratio.
In some cases, it isn't entirely clear
whether a bye week is an advantage or not, but in this case the College
Football Czar thinks it is a significant factor. Over the past month, the webfoots
have only played one really big game, beating Penn State for the Big Ten championship
after walking past rival Washington to end the regular season. Meanwhile, Steve Sarkisian's team has run the
gauntlet, beating arch enemy Texas A&M in a bruising defensive battle, then
taking a tough overtime loss against Georgia in the SEC title game, forcing themselves
to play a taxing first-round playoff game against ACC champion Clemson. One must wonder how they'll hold up if this
remains a close game into the fourth quarter, as it should.
It's a little-known fact that the
reason the Cotton Bowl is played at AT&T Stadium is because that venue was
built by Cotton, Hank's father on King of the Hill.
Oregon 37, Texas 33
Jan. 20
CFP Championship -- Atlanta -- 7:30
(ESPN)
Predicted matchup: Georgia (13-2)
vs. Oregon (15-0)
The Bulldogs are already 2-0 this
year in this same venue, having manhandled the Son of Clem in a 34-3 opener,
and scrapped their way past Texas, 22-19 in an overtime SEC championship. At the beginning of the 2022 season, they
delivered the Ducks a 49-3 posterior punting, in a game that was billed as a
possible national championship preview.
That was former UGA assistant Dan Lanning's first game as head coach at
UO, and he's not likely to experience another one like that anytime soon.
It might surprise many fans to find
that the Fighting Ducks have the statistically better defense between these
teams, with a slight edge across the board in rushing yards, passing yards and
points allowed. The Dogs were outgained
in their conference championship game, as well as in their eight-overtime
regular season finale against Georgia Tech.
The Quackers have come up on the short end in total yardage only twice
all season, against Boise State and Penn State.
The site of this national
championship game is Mercedes-Benz Stadium, but why Mercedes-Benz? Is she the long snapper?
Oregon 27, Georgia 10
a sports publication from The
Shinbone